Skip to main content

Ponting says it's 'well and truly' time to move on from Labuschagne

A disconsolate Marnus Labuschagne after being dismissed in Mackay
A disconsolate Marnus Labuschagne after being dismissed in MackayDAVID GRAY / AFP

Normal service resumed for Australia as their formidable bowling unit hit their marks in the second test against ⁠Bangladesh in Mackay but questions remain over a batting order that continues to misfire at the top.

Australia's innings and 51-run victory was a strong comeback from the Darwin ‌defeat as pace leaders Mitchell Starc and Pat Cummins blasted away the tourists' batters in a timely reminder of ‌their quality ahead of a tough, three-test tour of South Africa in October.

Australia's batting ‌has left selectors with a headache, though, and struggling number three Marnus Labuschagne may be nervous about ‌his place in the squad for South Africa.

South Africa-born Labuschagne was already under major ‌scrutiny after two poor dismissals in Darwin before he was bowled for four in Mackay by Shoriful Islam, the ball catching his thigh pad before hitting the stumps.

Upon his dismissal, Labuschagne gave the look of a ‌man forsaken by the cricketing gods and later took scissors ⁠to his thigh pad in an unusual ‌gear modification.

But behind the theatrics was a batter who had strayed far across his crease and given ​Shoriful a look at leg stump, further evidence for pundits of a need for change.

"There's some technical deficiency there, but he's making the margin for error for ​the bowlers too great," said former Australia captain Ricky Ponting.

"It's well and truly time to have a look at somebody else."

Labuschagne's exit would be the second top-order batter dropped in ⁠two matches after opener Jake Weatherald ​was dumped in the wake of the fiasco in Darwin, where Australia fell to a shock nine-wicket defeat.

Weatherald's replacement Matt Renshaw hardly inspired in his first test in over three years, falling for eight with a nick to the slips, but he will be afforded time to bed ‌into the role.

Whether Travis Head should accompany him at the top of the order remains a troublesome question for selectors.

Moved up from the middle order for the Ashes as Usman Khawaja struggled with injury, Head has remained there despite not really being seen as a proper opener.

Some former players, including Mark Waugh, want Head back down in the middle order but that would mean gambling with two unproven openers against South Africa, who beat Australia for the World Test Championship title last year.

With runs in Darwin and Mackay, Cameron Green has belatedly shored up his spot at number five so bringing Head back down would mean ‌upsetting the formula of having wicketkeeper Alex Carey at six and the second all-rounder Beau Webster at ​seven.

Selectors picked a thin 13-man squad for the Bangladesh series but are expected ‌to take at least 16 to South Africa and include additional batting cover.

Quite who gets the nod among the batters on the fringes is far from certain, with no real stand-out candidates having emerged.

Carey said there was no urgency to shake up Australia's batting lineup further.

"I think we felt a little bit like we left some runs ⁠out there (against Bangladesh), so we are always ⁠looking to improve as a batting unit," ‌he told reporters in Mackay.

"We are hungry. We are working really hard."

(Reporting by Ian Ransom; ​Editing by Peter Rutherford)